Clinical Research
Comparison of clinical efficacy of the new type of irrigation and aspiration therapy and vacuum sealing drainage in the treatment of high perianal abscess
Shaoquan Chen, Zaizhong Zhang, Liying Lin, Shuming Chen, Chengzhi Lin, Guoliang Huang, Lie Wang
Published 2018-07-08
Cite as Chin J Exp Surg, 2018, 35(7): 1335-1337. DOI: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.1001-9030.2018.07.047
Abstract
ObjectiveTo compare the clinical efficacy of the new type of irrigation and aspiration therapy and vacuum sealing drainage in the treatment of high perianal abscess.
Methods72 consecutive patients with high perianal abscess accepted to our department were randomized into the observation group and the control group, 36 cases in each group. The observation group underwent new type of irrigation and aspiration therapy and the control group underwent vacuum sealing drainage therapy. Preoperative, intraoperative and post-operative patient characteristics were evaluated.
ResultsCompared with control group, the incision length of observation group was significantly shorter [ (15.2±3.6) mm vs. (33.2±8.4) mm, t=-11.818, P=0.000], the operation time was significantly shorter too [ (14.2±2.6) min vs. (16.8±3.2) min, t=3.784, P=0.000], and the postoperative pain score was significantly lower [ (3.5±1.1) vs. (5.3±1.6), t=5.562, P=0.000], the wound healing time was significantly shorter [ (14.3±3.2) d vs. (18.2±4.8) d, t=-4.056, P=0.000]. While in wound healing rate (69.44% vs. 66.67%, χ2=0.064, P=0.800), fistula formation rate (22.22% vs. 25.00%, χ2=0.077, P=0.781), and abscess recurrence rate (5.56% vs. 8.33%, χ2=0.215, P=0.643), there were no significant differences between the two groups.
ConclusionThe new type of irrigation and aspiration therapy can reduce the surgical trauma, shorten the operative time, reduce the postoperative pain and shorten the wound healing time. The new type of irrigation and aspiration therapy is an effective method for minimally invasive treatment of high perianal abscess.
Key words:
Irrigation and aspiration therapy; Vacuum sealing irrigation and aspiration device; High perianal abscess; Vacuum sealing drainage
Contributor Information
Shaoquan Chen
Department of General Surgery, Fuzhou General Hospital of PLA, Dongfang Hospital Affiliated to Xiamen University, Fuzong Clinical Medical College of Fujian Medical University, Fuzhou 350025, China
Zaizhong Zhang
Liying Lin
Shuming Chen
Chengzhi Lin
Guoliang Huang
Lie Wang