Clinical Science
Clinical effect of pranoprofen eye drops for mild and moderate dry eye–a multicenter, randomized, controlled clinical trial
Jingyao Chen, Lixin Xie, Zuguo Liu, Hongsheng Bi, Wei Chen, Sanyou Dai, Yingping Deng, Pei Fu, Yangshun Gu, Jing Hong, Yifei Huang, Hui Jia, Li Jiang, Bing Li, Lin Li, Mingshun Li, Rongfeng Liao, Shiqi Ling, Dachuan Liu, Fangyi Liu, Hanqiang Liu, Hong Liu, Zhirong Liu, Ziyan Liu, Lin Ma, Hongren Qin, Junbo Rong, Yunliang Shao, Yuhua Shen, Majing Si, Guanfang Su, Hong Sun, Song Sun, Xuguang Sun, Hailin Wang, Jie Wang, Liya Wang, Linnong Wang, Jie Wu, Qun Wu, Hanping Xie, Like Xie, Weihua Xu, Xiaoming Yan, Yanning Yang, Xiaoming Yao, Juan Ye, Jin Yuan, Hong Zhang, Lijun Zhang, Liqiong Zhang, Mingchang Zhang, Yuhuan Zhang, Guiqiu Zhao, Shaozhen Zhao, Jinhua Zheng, Hongjian Zhou, Yongwei Zhu, Yuzhong Zhu, Linglong Tao
Published 2015-09-10
Cite as Chin J Exp Ophthalmol, 2015, 33(9): 834-839. DOI: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.2095-0160.2015.09.015
Abstract
BackgroundNonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs are widely used in the treatment of dry eye, but the related multicenter clinical study is lack.
ObjectiveThis study aimed to evaluate the clinic efficacy of pranoprofen eye drops for dry eye.
MethodsThis study protocol followed the Declaration of Helsinki, and oral informed consent was obtained from each patient prior to entering the cohort. A randomized, open, parallel, controlled, multi-center clinical trial was conducted. Total 1 023 patients with dry eye were enrolled based on the same diagnosis criteria in 58 eye institutes of China from July 2011 to July 2012. The patients was randomized into trial group and control group. The combination of 0. 1% pranoprofe dry drops (4 times per day) with 0. 1% sodium hyaluronate eye drops (4 times per day) was used in the trial group, and only 0. 1% sodium hyaluronate eye drops was used in the same way in the control group. The primary evaluated indexes included corneal fluorescence staining scores and break-up time of tear film (BUT), and secondary outcome measurements were the dry eye symptom scores and palpebral conjunctiva congestion and papilla scores as well as Shirmer Ⅰ test (SⅠt). The best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) and adverse response were compared between the two groups.
ResultsThe demography was matched between the two groups (both at P>0. 05). The corneal fluorescence staining scores were 0. 76±0. 66 and 0. 35±0. 54 in 14 days and 28 days after treatment in the trial group, which were lower than 1. 41±0. 58 before treatment (t=24. 439, 37. 236, both at P=0. 000); those in the control group were 0. 84±0. 65 and 0. 45±0. 60 in 14 and 28 days after treatment, with significant reduce in comparison with before treatment (1. 41±0. 62) (t=19. 702, 29. 517, both at P=0. 000). The corneal fluorescence staining score was significantly lower in the trial group compared with the control group in 28 days after treatment (t=8. 384, P=0. 004). The BUT was significantly delayed in 14 and 28 days after treatment compared with before treatment in the trial group (4. 88±2. 40)seconds and (6. 03±3. 25) seconds versus (3. 47±2. 10) seconds (t=-13. 358, -17. 734, both at P=0. 000), and so were the control group ([4. 62±2. 21] seconds and [5. 42±2. 70] seconds versus [3. 50±1. 52] seconds [t=-13. 984, t=-17. 879, both at P=0. 000]). The BUT was longer in the trial group compared with the control group in 28 days after treatment (t=10. 483, P=0. 001). In addition, the scores of dry eye symptom, palpebral conjunctiva congestion and papilla were significantly lower in the trial group than those in the control group in post-treated 14 and 28 days (all at P<0. 05). SⅠt was remarkably elevated and BCVA was considerably improved in the trial group compared with the control group in 28 days (t=9. 732, P=0. 002; t=-3. 687, P=0. 000). No significant difference was seen in the number of eyes with adverse response between the two groups (P>0. 05).
ConclusionsPranoprofen has a better anti-inflammatory effect on dry eye. The combination of 0. 1% pranoprofe dry drops with 0. 1% sodium hyaluronate eye drops can relieve dry eye symptoms and signs very well, especially in mild and moderate dry eye patients.
Key words:
Dry eye; Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs; Pranoprofen; Inflammation
Contributor Information
Jingyao Chen
Eye Institute of Xiamen University &
Xiamen Eye Center of Xiamen University, Xiamen 361001, China
Lixin Xie
Zuguo Liu
Hongsheng Bi
Wei Chen
Sanyou Dai
Yingping Deng
Pei Fu
Yangshun Gu
Jing Hong
Yifei Huang
Hui Jia
Li Jiang
Bing Li
Lin Li
Mingshun Li
Rongfeng Liao
Shiqi Ling
Dachuan Liu
Fangyi Liu
Hanqiang Liu
Hong Liu
Zhirong Liu
Ziyan Liu
Lin Ma
Hongren Qin
Junbo Rong
Yunliang Shao
Yuhua Shen
Majing Si
Guanfang Su
Hong Sun
Song Sun
Xuguang Sun
Hailin Wang
Jie Wang
Liya Wang
Linnong Wang
Jie Wu
Qun Wu
Hanping Xie
Like Xie
Weihua Xu
Xiaoming Yan
Yanning Yang
Xiaoming Yao
Juan Ye
Jin Yuan
Hong Zhang
Lijun Zhang
Liqiong Zhang
Mingchang Zhang
Yuhuan Zhang
Guiqiu Zhao
Shaozhen Zhao
Jinhua Zheng
Hongjian Zhou
Yongwei Zhu
Yuzhong Zhu
Linglong Tao